while some of my friends are having a comment-aquisition war, i'm over here blogging for peanuts with nary a comment to be found. no worries...like so many before me, my greatness will likely be unappreciated until years after my death.
i wanted to follow up on my last post regarding the future of the church and its ability to remain relevant in our culture, but i'm not exactly sure where to begin. i suppose my original intent was to enter into a pseudo-intellectual discourse about goal and purpose again, but after giving it some thought, i'm not sure that's the direction i want to go.
instead, i want to be a bit more transparent and acknowledge that i'm developing a blister in my spiritual life, caused by the constant friction i feel between church doctrine and the essential nature of christ's teachings. to prune that down, i'll define the "essential nature of christ's teachings" in his own words: to love god with all your heart, and to love your neighbor as yourself. "church doctrine" is simply all the other stuff that the church holds dear, for one reason or another. if you've been around the church for much time at all, i'm sure you can likely identify several issues that fit into the latter category.
there are rules, and there is The Rule, and i'm tired of the the rules being held as prerequisites to the kingdom. membership to the church no longer hinges on a belief in christ, but rather rests on our willingness to adhere to a set of doctrinal views. the idea that "we are all brothers and sisters in christ" does not extend as well from demonination to denomination as we like to believe. we make rules to define ourselves as a group, to create a sense of belonging to those inside...and too often forget that we may also be creating a sense of exclusion to those outside.
i grew up in the church of the nazarene, attended a baptist church with my grandparents when visiting them, and spent several years in a state where nearly all of my friends were lutheran or catholic. my wife was raised presbyterian, and we're currently attending a nondenominational-ish church with baptisty leanings. it would be impossible to follow all of the doctrinal rules for the different churches - issues like alcohol, tobacco, gender roles in the church, and sexual relationships vary widely enough, and if you add in more "religious" issues such as the nature of our relationship with christ, grace, and sanctification, things get more tortuous than my stomach can handle.
i've had religious leaders tell me directly: that the church is more forgiving of someone driving drunk than they are of two unmarried people living together, that alcohol is okay but tobacco is not, that female clergy are sinners, that god could strike a child dead for acting up in public, that without the church you cannot have a relationship with god, that you don't need the church to know god, that once you're forgiven you're always forgiven, that you can never be totally forgiven, and that if you are a good enough christian, you can reach a point where you never need to be forgiven because you no longer sin.
it's no wonder more people say they believe in god than believe in the church. only one of them can be infallible, and it ain't the church.
so what's a person to do? there's three options: (1) attend a church (2) don't attend a church, or (3) start your own church. they all have respective drawbacks: (1) limitations on your involvement and risk of being socially isolated, (2) loss of opportunities for fellowship with other believers and coporate worship, (3) being labeled a cultist and risk of recreating the same problems, among others. you lose regardless of your choice, but thus far i've opted for #1, as it seems to have the least number of drawbacks...or at least its drawbacks are the most comfortably familiar. it's shameful that we are comfortable and familiar with the church having shortcomings.
i don't really have any answers, just more questions. i am, however, thoroughly convinced that striving to embody love to others each day is not only the best way to live, it's the way of life that christ modeled for us. i'm less and less concerned with doctrine and more and more concerned with love. so, take all your rules, write them down, hang them on the wall, and try your hardest to follow them. i'm going to try my hardest to follow christ.
4 comments:
Agreed!!
It amazes me that to be "in" the church you must follow "their" rules, and that each church has "their own rules." I have found that each church is different, and I have yet to attend one that I completely agree with. It strikes me as amazing that the church claims to be the most open and forgiving, yet I have found it to be the most judgemental of all.
I am not saying that I don't like any of the churches that I have either been a member of or have attended, but you are only "in" as much as you follow "their" expectations/rules.
I also find it interesting that some who claim to be Christian are those who are the most comdeming and hurtful. Example being that if you do not follow their particular rule, you are asked to leave or better yet, told that you are going to hell for your belief or practice.
Anyway, it makes me wonder sometimes. It also makes me understand why some people say they believe in God and Jesus, but chose to not say they are a Christian.
Good post babe, I think you are right on. And guess what? I love you!
If you go to my blog, you will notice that since the competition for comments has since past, that I no longer get comments on blog postings that have any content.
Regarding your post, rather than post a full response here, I'd prefer to enjoy a meal, coffee, or dessert and discuss it in person. That is one of the luxuries of living in the same town.
You make some interesting observations and there have been many hurt by the 'church'. However, I have known many as well who have been blessed by Her as well.
Looking forward to good conversation soon.
Peace,
C-
yes, i echo casey ... with a few minor exceptions: Red Meat, Texas Beer, and British Tobacco ... that will get the conversation going (and much more fun than a trail of blog posts)! had a blast last night. thanks so much for celebrating with us. much love to you both.
My husband and I bought into the "love everyone as much as you can" philosophy years ago and left church behind us. Since then, I have felt a calmness that wasn't there before. When the rules are simple, life is simple, and for me, that works. Cathy
Post a Comment